Chiropractic Health & Wellness Blog

Consumers Reports July 2011

September 6, 2011
Back pain treatments

What helped our readers by Consumers Reports

Last reviewed: July 2011

Chiropractic outperformed all other back-pain treatments, and prescription medication rated about the same as deep-tissue massage, yoga, or Pilates. Over-the-counter medication was less helpful than hands-on therapies but performed about the same as progressive relaxation and meditation. (See the results for neck pain.)

What the research says!

Most back pain clears up on its own within a month or two. Staying active may curb pain and speed recovery. Acupuncture, chiropractic, and yoga are possibly effective for low-back pain. There might be some benefit to acupressure or meditation, but research is preliminary. A recent expert assessment found that spinal manipulation, exercise, standard medical care, and physical therapy appear to be equally helpful for low-back pain.

Precautions
See a doctor if you have back pain with fever, numbness, weakness, a change in bowel or bladder function, leg-muscle atrophy, a history of cancer, or pain associated with a recent trauma.

Back-pain treatments      % who used    % helped a lot

 
Chiropractic                             36%                 65%

Prescription medication           38%                 53%

Deep-tissue massage              24%                 51%

Yoga                                          9%                  49%

Pilates                                       3%                  49%

Acupressure                              3%                  45%

Swedish massage                     6%                  41%

Acupuncture                              8%                  41%

Shiatsu massage                      3%                   36%

Progressive relaxation              3%                   32%

Meditation                                 5%                   29%

Over-the-counter medication   58%                  28%

Deep-breathing exercises         6%                   23%

Magnesium supplements          4%                   15%

Glucosamine/chondroitin         14%                   12%

Vitamin D                                   8%                   10%


 
 
Differences of less than 5 percentage points are not meaningful.
Guide to the charts
The charts accompanying this report are based on responses to the 2010 Annual Questionnaire conducted by the Consumer Reports National Research Center. The red bars represent the proportion of readers using a treatment for a condition who said it “helped a lot.” Unless otherwise noted, the analysis of research findings came from the Natural Medicines Comprehensive Database, an independent research group, based on the scientific evidence that was current as of June 2011.
  • Medtronic Twin Cities Marathon Sponsor
  • Active Release Technologies
  • Rock Tape - Minnesota Chiropractor
  • Better Business Bureau - Minneapolis
  • Yelp - Minneapolis Chiropractor
  • Bizvotes - Minneapolis Chiropractor